Search
 
 

DYNAMICS - CASE STUDY SOLUTION


Elevator Diagram
 

To calculate the power required, both the force pulling the elevator up and the elevator's velocity must be determined.

The elevator's velocity, ve, is a constant 1 m/s and thus there is no acceleration (dv/dt = a = 0). The mass and dimensions of the elevator are given.

   
    Counterweight cable tension


Counterweight FBD
 

The counterweight, c, free-body diagram gives

     Tc = mc g

Remember, acceleration is assumed to be zero.

 

   
    Elevator cable tension


Elevator FBD
 

Using the free-body diagram for the elevator, e, and summing the forces in the vertical direction gives

     Tc + Te = mbg + meg

where mb is the mass of the bricks. Combining with the counterweight cable tension gives

     Te = (mb + mec)g

     
    Solution of a)


Counterweight = 800 kg
 

If the counterweight mass mc is 800 kg, then the tension in the cable is

     Te = (1000 + 1000 - 800) 9.81
         = 11.78 kN

The required power output is

     Po = Te ve
          = 11.78 (1)
          = 11.78 kW

Motors and mechanical equipment will lose energy from other sources, such as friction. Thus the motor has to deliver more power than what is actually being lifted.The, mechanical efficiency, η, is

     
     0.8 = 11.78/Pi
     Pi = 14.73 kW

     
    Solution of b)


Counterweight = 0 kg

 

If the counterweight mass, mc, is 0 kg, then tension in the cable will be

     Te = (1000 + 1000 - 0) 9.81
         = 19.62 kN

The required power output is

     Po = Te ve
          = 19.62 (1)
          = 19.62 kW

Considering the motor efficiency, η, gives

     
     0.8 = 19.62/Pi
     Pi = 24.53 kW

     
   

Comparison between the elevator with and without the counterweight can now be done.

     Pc = 800 = 14.73 kW
     Pc = 0 = 24.53 kW

The increase in power without the counterweight is

     (24.53 - 14.73)/14.73 = 67%

     
   
 
Practice Homework and Test problems now available in the 'Eng Dynamics' mobile app
Includes over 400 free problems with complete detailed solutions.
Available at the Google Play Store and Apple App Store.